Saturday, March 26, 2022

The List of Unspeakable Fears, by J. Kasper Kramer

     Essie O'Neill is afraid of many things - electric lights, cats, and the red door at the end of the hallway in her new home. She keeps a list of her fears under her mattress so she can add to it at any time. Sometimes, adding to her list helps her fears seem less scary...sometimes. And sometimes she can cross things of of her list...sometimes.

    This historical fiction book takes place in New York in the early 1900s in the midst of the typhoid epidemic - not terribly different from our current Covid pandemic -  and during a time of racism and anger towards immigrants. In the story, Essie's new stepfather is German, and in charge of a hospital treating people thought to carry very contagious diseases, such as typhoid fever. One of the characters of the book is Typhoid Mary, a real person who is thought to have spread typhoid as a carrier and a cook in New York City. Essie is also reeling from the death of her biological father, who had gotten sick and died as well, while under the care of Essie, who feels responsible for his death. Her stepfather, meanwhile, is dealing with severe loss of his own, a daughter that Essie "meets" in her new home on the quarantined island where she and her mother move when her mother remarries. Together, Essie's fears, disease, bigotry, a new family, a very strange cat and ghosts make for a pretty good page-turner!

    Some reviewers write that this book is a combination of Coraline and The War That Saved My Life, two very good books that I recommend to you! I don't know if I would go so far as to say this was as good as either of those, but the story and characters have stayed with me, which I always feel is a very good sign! 

    In the author's notes at the end of the book she describes how closely Essie's story resembles her own, especially in light of what we have lived through in the last two years of Covid quarantines, illnesses, deaths and strong feelings about all of it. Having that background information made The List of Unspeakable Fears seem a little like the author's personal therapy session. That isn't a terrible thing all together, but seemed a tad self-serving. In all, this is a good story, somewhat spooky and quirky, which I enjoyed, but also a bit easy to figure out, which I was a little disappointed in. I think 4 paws is a good way to balance those thoughts, so that is what I'll give this one. Worth your time, but I wonder what Kramer will write next.



No comments:

Post a Comment

Two Roads, by Joseph Bruchac

     It's been a minute since I've read a Joseph Bruchac book - actually, several minutes - but I am glad to have come back! He is ...